6.5 指标对比 & SOTA

状态:Stage 6.5 是 SOTA 证据索引页,不直接产生 SOTA 结论。只有 paper_metric_result_verified.csv 中的高置信记录才允许进入 sota_rankings.md

当前结论

  • 当前 verified rows: 0
  • 若 verified rows 为 0,系统不能回答“谁是 SOTA”,只能回答“哪些结果值得复核/精读”。
  • 已新增 paper_metric_result_raw.csv / paper_metric_result_review_queue.csv / paper_metric_result_verified.csv 三层产物。
  • paper_metric_result.csv/md 是兼容旧入口的 raw 结果;正式 SOTA 排序只读取 verified 结果。
  • candidate_comparable=yes 表示进入 review queue;正式 SOTA 排序前仍需人工确认 split / resolution / sample_count / backbone / baseline_retrained。comparable=yes 只允许 verified 层使用。

结构化产物索引

产物 用途 当前数量/状态
paper_metric_result_raw.csv 自动抽表全量结果 2809
paper_metric_result_review_queue.csv 待人工/agent 复核候选;公开预览隐藏 value 84
paper_metric_result_verified.csv 高置信可排序行 0
paper_dataset_role_map_v2.csv dataset role gate / sota_eligible / block reason dataset gate
dataset_registry.csv dataset canonical / alias / modality / official metadata registry draft
paper_claims.csv 强 claim 抽取与降级 338
claim_to_metric_review_queue.csv 强 claim 到 metric review rows 的复核队列 review queue
sota_rankings.md 只从 verified rows 生成分榜 暂无 verified ranking
sota_candidate_evidence.md 高风险候选证据附录,不可直接生成结论 140
read_priority.csv 论文精读入口 29

Rankable Status 统计

rankable_status rows
missing_dataset 2089
dataset_header_conflict 221
dataset_role=reference_only 197
ablation_only 88
needs_human_verify 84
missing_protocol 57
method_parse_suspect=empty_method 32
dataset_role=pretrain_source 23
method_parse_suspect=task_or_category_header 12
missing_metric_scope 6

当前精读队列摘录(不是性能/排行)

论文 score survey_score evidence_score band task why_read
CubeDiff: Repurposing Diffusion-Based Image Models for Panorama Generation 88 68 20 high image_or_nfov_to_panorama core paper; code available; confirmed pipeline figure; 68 metric rows need ranking QA; cubemap
Conditional Panoramic Image Generation via Masked Autoregressive Modeling 75 70 5 high panorama_generation_general core paper; code available; confirmed pipeline figure; 64 metric rows extracted but not rankable; masked_autoregressive
JoPano: Unified Panorama Generation via Joint Modeling 75 70 5 high panorama_generation_general core paper; code available; confirmed pipeline figure; 118 metric rows extracted but not rankable; unified_omni_model
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation 65 60 5 high text_to_panorama core paper; code available; confirmed pipeline figure; 112 metric rows extracted but not rankable
What Makes for Text to 360-degree Panorama Generation with Stable Diffusion? 65 60 5 high text_to_panorama core paper; code available; confirmed pipeline figure; 111 metric rows extracted but not rankable
Spherical manifold guided diffusion model for panoramic image generation 63 58 5 high panorama_generation_general core paper; confirmed pipeline figure; 100 metric rows extracted but not rankable; spherical_latent_or_manifold
SphereDiff: Tuning-free 360° Static and Dynamic Panorama Generation via Spherical Latent Representation 61 56 5 high panorama_generation_general core paper; code available; figure=partial_method_figure; 13 metric rows extracted but not rankable; spherical_latent_or_manifold
CamFreeDiff: camera-free image to panorama generation with diffusion model 55 50 5 high image_or_nfov_to_panorama core paper; confirmed pipeline figure; 47 metric rows extracted but not rankable
Spherical-nested diffusion model for panoramic image outpainting 54 38 16 medium panorama_outpainting core paper; 16 metric rows need ranking QA; spherical_latent_or_manifold
TanDiT: Tangent-Plane Diffusion Transformer for High-Quality 360 {\deg} Panorama Generation 53 48 5 medium panorama_generation_general core paper; 252 metric rows extracted but not rankable; diffusion_transformer; tangent_plane

Paper Claim Guard

下表只表示论文/NotebookLM 文本中的强 claim 被抽到,默认都是 paper_claim_until_metric_supported。当 verified rows 为 0 时,综述生成器不得把这些 claim 写成系统结论。

claim_type rows
novelty_claim 189
sota_claim 99
performance_claim 38
significance_claim 12
论文 claim_type status trigger metric_ctx dataset_ctx
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported state-of-the-art no no
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported SoTA yes no
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported State-of-the-art no yes
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported State-of-the-art no no
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported state-of-the-art no no
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported First no no
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
Diffusion360: Seamless 360 Degree Panoramic Image Generation based on Diffusion Models novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no yes
Diffusion360: Seamless 360 Degree Panoramic Image Generation based on Diffusion Models novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
360-Degree Panorama Generation from Few Unregistered NFoV Images sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported state-of-the-art no no
360-Degree Panorama Generation from Few Unregistered NFoV Images sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported SOTA no yes
360-Degree Panorama Generation from Few Unregistered NFoV Images novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported First no no
360-Degree Panorama Generation from Few Unregistered NFoV Images novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
360-Degree Panorama Generation from Few Unregistered NFoV Images novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
360-Degree Panorama Generation from Few Unregistered NFoV Images novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
360-Degree Panorama Generation from Few Unregistered NFoV Images novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
360-Degree Panorama Generation from Few Unregistered NFoV Images novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
360-Degree Panorama Generation from Few Unregistered NFoV Images novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
360-Degree Panorama Generation from Few Unregistered NFoV Images novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
360-Degree Panorama Generation from Few Unregistered NFoV Images novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
360-Degree Panorama Generation from Few Unregistered NFoV Images performance_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported outperforms no no
Panorama Generation From NFoV Image Done Right sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported SOTA yes yes
Panorama Generation From NFoV Image Done Right sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported SOTA no yes
Panorama Generation From NFoV Image Done Right sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported state-of-the-art yes yes
Panorama Generation From NFoV Image Done Right novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first yes no
Panorama Generation From NFoV Image Done Right novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
Panorama Generation From NFoV Image Done Right novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
Panorama Generation From NFoV Image Done Right novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
Panorama Generation From NFoV Image Done Right novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first yes no
Panorama Generation From NFoV Image Done Right novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no yes
Panorama Generation From NFoV Image Done Right novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
Panorama Generation From NFoV Image Done Right novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
Panorama Generation From NFoV Image Done Right novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
PanoDiffusion: 360-degree Panorama Outpainting via Diffusion sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported state-of-the-art no no
PanoDiffusion: 360-degree Panorama Outpainting via Diffusion sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported state-of-the-art no no
PanoDiffusion: 360-degree Panorama Outpainting via Diffusion sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported state-of-the-art yes yes
PanoDiffusion: 360-degree Panorama Outpainting via Diffusion sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported state-of-the-art no no
PanoDiffusion: 360-degree Panorama Outpainting via Diffusion novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported First no yes
PanoDiffusion: 360-degree Panorama Outpainting via Diffusion novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
PanoDiffusion: 360-degree Panorama Outpainting via Diffusion performance_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported outperforms no no
PanoDiffusion: 360-degree Panorama Outpainting via Diffusion performance_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported outperforms no yes
PanoDiffusion: 360-degree Panorama Outpainting via Diffusion performance_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported outperform yes yes
PanoDiffusion: 360-degree Panorama Outpainting via Diffusion performance_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported outperforms no no
PanoDiffusion: 360-degree Panorama Outpainting via Diffusion performance_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported outperforms no no
PanoDiffusion: 360-degree Panorama Outpainting via Diffusion performance_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported best no no
What Makes for Text to 360-degree Panorama Generation with Stable Diffusion? sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported SoTA no no
What Makes for Text to 360-degree Panorama Generation with Stable Diffusion? sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported SoTA yes no
What Makes for Text to 360-degree Panorama Generation with Stable Diffusion? sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported SoTA yes no
What Makes for Text to 360-degree Panorama Generation with Stable Diffusion? sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported state-of-the-art yes no
What Makes for Text to 360-degree Panorama Generation with Stable Diffusion? sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported state-of-the-art no no
What Makes for Text to 360-degree Panorama Generation with Stable Diffusion? sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported state-of-the-art no no
What Makes for Text to 360-degree Panorama Generation with Stable Diffusion? sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported State-of-the-art no no
What Makes for Text to 360-degree Panorama Generation with Stable Diffusion? sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported state-of-the-art no no
What Makes for Text to 360-degree Panorama Generation with Stable Diffusion? sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported SoTA no no
What Makes for Text to 360-degree Panorama Generation with Stable Diffusion? novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
What Makes for Text to 360-degree Panorama Generation with Stable Diffusion? novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
What Makes for Text to 360-degree Panorama Generation with Stable Diffusion? novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
DiffPano++: Scalable and Consistent Multi-View Panorama Generation with Spherical Epipolar-Aware Diffusion sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported SOTA no no
DiffPano++: Scalable and Consistent Multi-View Panorama Generation with Spherical Epipolar-Aware Diffusion novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
DiffPano++: Scalable and Consistent Multi-View Panorama Generation with Spherical Epipolar-Aware Diffusion novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
DiffPano++: Scalable and Consistent Multi-View Panorama Generation with Spherical Epipolar-Aware Diffusion novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
DiffPano++: Scalable and Consistent Multi-View Panorama Generation with Spherical Epipolar-Aware Diffusion novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no yes
DiffPano++: Scalable and Consistent Multi-View Panorama Generation with Spherical Epipolar-Aware Diffusion novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
DiffPano++: Scalable and Consistent Multi-View Panorama Generation with Spherical Epipolar-Aware Diffusion novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
DiffPano++: Scalable and Consistent Multi-View Panorama Generation with Spherical Epipolar-Aware Diffusion novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
DiffPano++: Scalable and Consistent Multi-View Panorama Generation with Spherical Epipolar-Aware Diffusion novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first yes no
DiffPano++: Scalable and Consistent Multi-View Panorama Generation with Spherical Epipolar-Aware Diffusion novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first yes no
DiffPano++: Scalable and Consistent Multi-View Panorama Generation with Spherical Epipolar-Aware Diffusion novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported First no no
DiffPano++: Scalable and Consistent Multi-View Panorama Generation with Spherical Epipolar-Aware Diffusion novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
Spherical manifold guided diffusion model for panoramic image generation sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported state-of-the-art no no
Spherical manifold guided diffusion model for panoramic image generation sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported state-of-the-art no no
Spherical manifold guided diffusion model for panoramic image generation sota_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported state-of-the-art no no
Spherical manifold guided diffusion model for panoramic image generation novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
Spherical manifold guided diffusion model for panoramic image generation novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no
Spherical manifold guided diffusion model for panoramic image generation novelty_claim paper_claim_until_metric_supported first no no

禁止下游直接使用的字段

字段/章节 原因 允许用法
sota_candidate_evidence.md 包含论文原文强 claim,尚未 verified 只能写“作者声称/待复核候选”
paper_claims.csv 强 claim 抽取层,不是事实层 用于 claim audit 和精读队列
paper_metric_result_review_queue.csv 候选可比,不是高置信可比 人工/agent 复核后才能晋升 verified
evidence_score 待复核证据量,不代表方法更强 用于决定先复核哪些论文

不可比风险清单

风险 说明
任务不同 text-to-panorama、NFoV-to-panorama、outpainting、editing、video 不能混排。
数据集不同 SUN360、Matterport3D、Structured3D、Laval、Pano360 等不可直接合榜。
评测区域不同 ERP 全图、裁剪区域、cubemap/tangent view、perspective projection 指标不可直接比较。
指标实现不同 FID/CLIPScore 依赖 backbone、参考集、样本数、分辨率。
baseline 不公平 有些表格重训 baseline,有些直接引用原论文结果。

可比性规则

  • 同数据集。
  • 同任务,例如 text-to-panorama、NFoV-to-panorama、outpainting、editing 不混排。
  • 同指标,且方向一致。
  • 同分辨率、采样数量、评测 split、CLIP/FID backbone 等设置尽量一致。
  • 不同论文计算方式不同的,放入注意事项,不进入 SOTA 排序。

指标出现频次

指标 出现论文数
CLIPScore 39
FID 26
Inception Score 25
accuracy 12
FAED 8
user study 8
LPIPS 7
PSNR 7
CLIP-FID 5
KID 5
preference 5
SSIM 4
sFID 3
DS 3
RS 2
IoU 2
RMSE 2
MAE 2
AbsREL 2
OmniFID 2
runtime 2
CLIP-aesthetic 2
Distort-FID 1
Delta1.25 1
TangentFID 1
TangentIS 1
Seam-SSIM 1
Seam-Sobel 1
ImageReward 1
CMMD 1
DISTS 1
DINO-score 1
TFLOPs 1
latency 1
Intra-LPIPS 1
Cross-LPIPS 1
FVD 1

SOTA 候选证据附录

高风险长文本候选证据已移到 sota_candidate_evidence.md / sota_candidate_evidence.csv。这些文本不能绕过 paper_claims.csv 和 verified hard gate,不能直接生成“领先/SOTA/最佳”等结论。

Metric Table Candidates

parse_hint_unverified 只表示表格解析线索,不代表已经形成可排序 comparable group。

论文 table metrics datasets status parse_hint_unverified
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation 1 CLIPScore;FAED;FID;Inception Score needs_structured_parse
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation 2 CLIPScore;FAED;FID;Inception Score needs_structured_parse
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation 3 CLIPScore;FID;Inception Score;IoU needs_structured_parse
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation 4 weak_table_candidate
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation 5 CLIPScore;FID;Inception Score needs_structured_parse
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation 6 CLIPScore;RS needs_structured_parse
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation 7 CLIPScore;FID;Inception Score;IoU;RS needs_structured_parse
360-Degree Panorama Generation from Few Unregistered NFoV Images 1 FID LAVAL;SUN360 needs_structured_parse image_or_nfov_to_panorama|LAVAL|FID
360-Degree Panorama Generation from Few Unregistered NFoV Images 2 LAVAL;LAVAL Indoor;Laval Indoor;SUN360 weak_table_candidate
360-Degree Panorama Generation from Few Unregistered NFoV Images 3 FID needs_structured_parse
Panorama Generation From NFoV Image Done Right 1 SUN360 weak_table_candidate
Panorama Generation From NFoV Image Done Right 2 CLIP-FID;Distort-FID;FID;Inception Score LAVAL;LAVAL Indoor;Laval Indoor;SUN360 needs_structured_parse image_or_nfov_to_panorama|LAVAL|CLIP-FID
Panorama Generation From NFoV Image Done Right 3 CLIP-FID;Distort-FID;FID;Inception Score needs_structured_parse
Panorama Generation From NFoV Image Done Right 4 CLIP-FID;Distort-FID;FID;Inception Score needs_structured_parse
PanoDiffusion: 360-degree Panorama Outpainting via Diffusion 1 FID;sFID needs_structured_parse
PanoDiffusion: 360-degree Panorama Outpainting via Diffusion 2 FID;sFID Structured3D needs_structured_parse panorama_outpainting|Structured3D|FID
PanoDiffusion: 360-degree Panorama Outpainting via Diffusion 3 FID;sFID needs_structured_parse
PanoDiffusion: 360-degree Panorama Outpainting via Diffusion 4 AbsREL;Delta1.25;MAE;RMSE needs_structured_parse
PanoDiffusion: 360-degree Panorama Outpainting via Diffusion 5 weak_table_candidate
What Makes for Text to 360-degree Panorama Generation with Stable Diffusion? 1 FAED;FID needs_structured_parse
What Makes for Text to 360-degree Panorama Generation with Stable Diffusion? 2 FAED;FID needs_structured_parse
What Makes for Text to 360-degree Panorama Generation with Stable Diffusion? 3 CLIPScore;FAED;FID;Inception Score needs_structured_parse
What Makes for Text to 360-degree Panorama Generation with Stable Diffusion? 4 FAED;FID needs_structured_parse
What Makes for Text to 360-degree Panorama Generation with Stable Diffusion? 5 FAED;FID needs_structured_parse
DiffPano++: Scalable and Consistent Multi-View Panorama Generation with Spherical Epipolar-Aware Diffusion 1 CLIPScore;FID;Inception Score needs_structured_parse
DiffPano++: Scalable and Consistent Multi-View Panorama Generation with Spherical Epipolar-Aware Diffusion 2 CLIPScore;FID;Inception Score;PSNR;SSIM;user study needs_structured_parse
DiffPano++: Scalable and Consistent Multi-View Panorama Generation with Spherical Epipolar-Aware Diffusion 3 CLIPScore;FID;Inception Score;PSNR;SSIM needs_structured_parse
DiffPano++: Scalable and Consistent Multi-View Panorama Generation with Spherical Epipolar-Aware Diffusion 4 CLIPScore;FID;Inception Score;LPIPS;PSNR;SSIM needs_structured_parse
DiffPano++: Scalable and Consistent Multi-View Panorama Generation with Spherical Epipolar-Aware Diffusion 5 FID;Inception Score needs_structured_parse
DiffPano++: Scalable and Consistent Multi-View Panorama Generation with Spherical Epipolar-Aware Diffusion 6 weak_table_candidate
DiffPano++: Scalable and Consistent Multi-View Panorama Generation with Spherical Epipolar-Aware Diffusion 7 weak_table_candidate
Spherical manifold guided diffusion model for panoramic image generation 1 CLIPScore;FAED;FID;OmniFID needs_structured_parse
Spherical manifold guided diffusion model for panoramic image generation 2 CLIPScore;FID needs_structured_parse
Spherical-nested diffusion model for panoramic image outpainting 1 FID Matterport3D;Structured3D needs_structured_parse panorama_outpainting|Matterport3D|FID
Spherical-nested diffusion model for panoramic image outpainting 2 FID Matterport3D;Structured3D needs_structured_parse panorama_outpainting|Matterport3D|FID
Spherical-nested diffusion model for panoramic image outpainting 3 FID Matterport3D needs_structured_parse panorama_outpainting|Matterport3D|FID
Spherical-nested diffusion model for panoramic image outpainting 4 FID needs_structured_parse
Spherical-nested diffusion model for panoramic image outpainting 5 FID Matterport3D needs_structured_parse panorama_outpainting|Matterport3D|FID
Spherical-nested diffusion model for panoramic image outpainting 6 FID Matterport3D needs_structured_parse panorama_outpainting|Matterport3D|FID
CubeDiff: Repurposing Diffusion-Based Image Models for Panorama Generation 1 CLIP-FID;CLIPScore;FAED;FID;KID LAVAL;LAVAL Indoor;Laval Indoor;SUN360 needs_structured_parse image_or_nfov_to_panorama|LAVAL|CLIP-FID
CubeDiff: Repurposing Diffusion-Based Image Models for Panorama Generation 2 CLIP-FID;FID;KID LAVAL;LAVAL Indoor;Laval Indoor;SUN360 needs_structured_parse image_or_nfov_to_panorama|LAVAL|CLIP-FID
Conditional Panoramic Image Generation via Masked Autoregressive Modeling 1 CLIPScore;DS;FAED;FID Matterport3D needs_structured_parse panorama_generation_general|Matterport3D|CLIPScore
Conditional Panoramic Image Generation via Masked Autoregressive Modeling 2 FID Matterport3D needs_structured_parse panorama_generation_general|Matterport3D|FID
Conditional Panoramic Image Generation via Masked Autoregressive Modeling 3 CLIPScore;DS;FID needs_structured_parse
Conditional Panoramic Image Generation via Masked Autoregressive Modeling 4 FID needs_structured_parse
Conditional Panoramic Image Generation via Masked Autoregressive Modeling 5 FID needs_structured_parse
Conditional Panoramic Image Generation via Masked Autoregressive Modeling 6 CLIPScore;DS;FAED;FID Matterport3D needs_structured_parse panorama_generation_general|Matterport3D|CLIPScore
Conditional Panoramic Image Generation via Masked Autoregressive Modeling 7 CLIPScore;DS;FAED;FID Matterport3D needs_structured_parse panorama_generation_general|Matterport3D|CLIPScore
Conditional Panoramic Image Generation via Masked Autoregressive Modeling 8 FID Matterport3D needs_structured_parse panorama_generation_general|Matterport3D|FID
Conditional Panoramic Image Generation via Masked Autoregressive Modeling 9 FID needs_structured_parse
Conditional Panoramic Image Generation via Masked Autoregressive Modeling 10 CLIPScore;DS;FID Structured3D needs_structured_parse panorama_generation_general|Structured3D|CLIPScore
Conditional Panoramic Image Generation via Masked Autoregressive Modeling 11 CLIPScore;DS;FID Structured3D needs_structured_parse panorama_generation_general|Structured3D|CLIPScore
DiffPano: Scalable and Consistent Text to Panorama Generation with Spherical Epipolar-Aware Diffusion 1 CLIPScore;FID;Inception Score needs_structured_parse
DiffPano: Scalable and Consistent Text to Panorama Generation with Spherical Epipolar-Aware Diffusion 2 CLIPScore;FID;Inception Score;PSNR;SSIM;user study needs_structured_parse
DiffPano: Scalable and Consistent Text to Panorama Generation with Spherical Epipolar-Aware Diffusion 3 CLIPScore;FID;Inception Score;PSNR;SSIM needs_structured_parse
DiffPano: Scalable and Consistent Text to Panorama Generation with Spherical Epipolar-Aware Diffusion 4 CLIPScore;FID;Inception Score;LPIPS;PSNR;SSIM needs_structured_parse
DiffPano: Scalable and Consistent Text to Panorama Generation with Spherical Epipolar-Aware Diffusion 5 FID;Inception Score needs_structured_parse
DiffPano: Scalable and Consistent Text to Panorama Generation with Spherical Epipolar-Aware Diffusion 6 weak_table_candidate
DiffPano: Scalable and Consistent Text to Panorama Generation with Spherical Epipolar-Aware Diffusion 7 weak_table_candidate
CamFreeDiff: camera-free image to panorama generation with diffusion model 1 CLIPScore;FID;Inception Score;PSNR Matterport3D;Structured3D needs_structured_parse image_or_nfov_to_panorama|Matterport3D|CLIPScore
CamFreeDiff: camera-free image to panorama generation with diffusion model 2 CLIPScore;FID;Inception Score;PSNR Structured3D needs_structured_parse image_or_nfov_to_panorama|Structured3D|CLIPScore
CamFreeDiff: camera-free image to panorama generation with diffusion model 3 CLIPScore;FID;Inception Score;PSNR Matterport3D needs_structured_parse image_or_nfov_to_panorama|Matterport3D|CLIPScore
CamFreeDiff: camera-free image to panorama generation with diffusion model 4 Matterport3D weak_table_candidate
CamFreeDiff: camera-free image to panorama generation with diffusion model 5 CLIPScore;FID;Inception Score;PSNR Structured3D needs_structured_parse image_or_nfov_to_panorama|Structured3D|CLIPScore
TanDiT: Tangent-Plane Diffusion Transformer for High-Quality 360 {\deg} Panorama Generation 1 weak_table_candidate
TanDiT: Tangent-Plane Diffusion Transformer for High-Quality 360 {\deg} Panorama Generation 2 CLIPScore;DS;FAED;FID;Inception Score;KID;OmniFID;TangentFID;TangentIS needs_structured_parse
TanDiT: Tangent-Plane Diffusion Transformer for High-Quality 360 {\deg} Panorama Generation 3 CLIPScore;DS;FAED;FID;Inception Score;KID;OmniFID;TangentFID;TangentIS needs_structured_parse
TanDiT: Tangent-Plane Diffusion Transformer for High-Quality 360 {\deg} Panorama Generation 4 weak_table_candidate
TanDiT: Tangent-Plane Diffusion Transformer for High-Quality 360 {\deg} Panorama Generation 5 CLIPScore;DS;FAED;FID;Inception Score;KID;OmniFID;TangentFID;TangentIS needs_structured_parse
TanDiT: Tangent-Plane Diffusion Transformer for High-Quality 360 {\deg} Panorama Generation 6 CLIPScore;DS;FAED;FID;Inception Score;KID;OmniFID;TangentFID;TangentIS needs_structured_parse
TanDiT: Tangent-Plane Diffusion Transformer for High-Quality 360 {\deg} Panorama Generation 7 CLIPScore;DS;FAED;FID;Inception Score;KID;OmniFID;TangentFID;TangentIS needs_structured_parse
TanDiT: Tangent-Plane Diffusion Transformer for High-Quality 360 {\deg} Panorama Generation 8 CLIPScore;DS;FAED;FID;Inception Score;KID;OmniFID;TangentFID;TangentIS needs_structured_parse
TanDiT: Tangent-Plane Diffusion Transformer for High-Quality 360 {\deg} Panorama Generation 9 CLIPScore;DS;FAED;FID;Inception Score;KID;OmniFID;TangentFID;TangentIS needs_structured_parse
TanDiT: Tangent-Plane Diffusion Transformer for High-Quality 360 {\deg} Panorama Generation 10 CLIPScore;DS;FAED;FID;Inception Score;KID;OmniFID;TangentFID;TangentIS needs_structured_parse
SphereDiff: Tuning-free 360° Static and Dynamic Panorama Generation via Spherical Latent Representation 1 weak_table_candidate
SphereDiff: Tuning-free 360° Static and Dynamic Panorama Generation via Spherical Latent Representation 2 CLIPScore;user study needs_structured_parse
SphereDiff: Tuning-free 360° Static and Dynamic Panorama Generation via Spherical Latent Representation 3 CLIPScore;runtime needs_structured_parse
SphereDiff: Tuning-free 360° Static and Dynamic Panorama Generation via Spherical Latent Representation 4 weak_table_candidate
JoPano: Unified Panorama Generation via Joint Modeling 1 CLIP-FID;CLIPScore;FID;Inception Score SUN360;Structure3D needs_structured_parse panorama_generation_general|SUN360|CLIP-FID
JoPano: Unified Panorama Generation via Joint Modeling 2 CLIP-FID;FID;Inception Score;SSIM;Seam-SSIM;Seam-Sobel SUN360 needs_structured_parse panorama_generation_general|SUN360|CLIP-FID

Paper Metric Result Preview

公开 markdown 只展示 value_hidden。真实数值保留在 CSV 供人工/agent 复核,不能被下游当成榜单。

论文 method method_row_role method_parse_suspect dataset metric value_hidden metric_scope comparable_group comparable candidate_comparable rankable_status allowed_use do_not_rank ranking_allowed reason
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Text2Light [4] baseline_or_reported_method no FAED hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Text2Light [4] baseline_or_reported_method no FID hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Text2Light [4] baseline_or_reported_method no Inception Score hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Text2Light [4] baseline_or_reported_method no CLIPScore hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Text2Light [4] baseline_or_reported_method no FID hidden_in_public_md 20 Views no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Text2Light [4] baseline_or_reported_method no Inception Score hidden_in_public_md 20 Views no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Text2Light [4] baseline_or_reported_method no FID hidden_in_public_md Horizontal 8 Views [47] no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Text2Light [4] baseline_or_reported_method no Inception Score hidden_in_public_md Horizontal 8 Views [47] no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Text2Light [4] baseline_or_reported_method no CLIPScore hidden_in_public_md Horizontal 8 Views [47] no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation MVDiffusion [47] baseline_or_reported_method no FID hidden_in_public_md Horizontal 8 Views [47] no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation MVDiffusion [47] baseline_or_reported_method no Inception Score hidden_in_public_md Horizontal 8 Views [47] no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation MVDiffusion [47] baseline_or_reported_method no CLIPScore hidden_in_public_md Horizontal 8 Views [47] no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation SD+LoRA [14, 31] baseline_or_reported_method no FAED hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation SD+LoRA [14, 31] baseline_or_reported_method no FID hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation SD+LoRA [14, 31] baseline_or_reported_method no Inception Score hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation SD+LoRA [14, 31] baseline_or_reported_method no CLIPScore hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation SD+LoRA [14, 31] baseline_or_reported_method no FID hidden_in_public_md 20 Views no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation SD+LoRA [14, 31] baseline_or_reported_method no Inception Score hidden_in_public_md 20 Views no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation SD+LoRA [14, 31] baseline_or_reported_method no FID hidden_in_public_md Horizontal 8 Views [47] no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation SD+LoRA [14, 31] baseline_or_reported_method no Inception Score hidden_in_public_md Horizontal 8 Views [47] no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation SD+LoRA [14, 31] baseline_or_reported_method no CLIPScore hidden_in_public_md Horizontal 8 Views [47] no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Pano Branch baseline_or_reported_method no FAED hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Pano Branch baseline_or_reported_method no FID hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Pano Branch baseline_or_reported_method no Inception Score hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Pano Branch baseline_or_reported_method no CLIPScore hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Pano Branch baseline_or_reported_method no FID hidden_in_public_md 20 Views no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Pano Branch baseline_or_reported_method no Inception Score hidden_in_public_md 20 Views no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Pano Branch baseline_or_reported_method no FID hidden_in_public_md Horizontal 8 Views [47] no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Pano Branch baseline_or_reported_method no Inception Score hidden_in_public_md Horizontal 8 Views [47] no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Pano Branch baseline_or_reported_method no CLIPScore hidden_in_public_md Horizontal 8 Views [47] no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation PanFusion (Ours) current_method no FAED hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation PanFusion (Ours) current_method no FID hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation PanFusion (Ours) current_method no Inception Score hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation PanFusion (Ours) current_method no CLIPScore hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation PanFusion (Ours) current_method no FID hidden_in_public_md 20 Views no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation PanFusion (Ours) current_method no Inception Score hidden_in_public_md 20 Views no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation PanFusion (Ours) current_method no FID hidden_in_public_md Horizontal 8 Views [47] no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation PanFusion (Ours) current_method no Inception Score hidden_in_public_md Horizontal 8 Views [47] no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation PanFusion (Ours) current_method no CLIPScore hidden_in_public_md Horizontal 8 Views [47] no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Pano Branch baseline_or_reported_method no FAED hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Pano Branch baseline_or_reported_method no FID hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Pano Branch baseline_or_reported_method no Inception Score hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Pano Branch baseline_or_reported_method no CLIPScore hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Pano Branch baseline_or_reported_method no FID hidden_in_public_md 20 Views no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Pano Branch baseline_or_reported_method no Inception Score hidden_in_public_md 20 Views no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours-joint current_method no FAED hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours-joint current_method no FID hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours-joint current_method no Inception Score hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours-joint current_method no CLIPScore hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours-joint current_method no FID hidden_in_public_md 20 Views no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours-joint current_method no Inception Score hidden_in_public_md 20 Views no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours-SPE current_method no FAED hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours-SPE current_method no FID hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours-SPE current_method no Inception Score hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours-SPE current_method no CLIPScore hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours-SPE current_method no FID hidden_in_public_md 20 Views no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours-SPE current_method no Inception Score hidden_in_public_md 20 Views no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours-mask current_method no FAED hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours-mask current_method no FID hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours-mask current_method no Inception Score hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours-mask current_method no CLIPScore hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours-mask current_method no FID hidden_in_public_md 20 Views no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours-mask current_method no Inception Score hidden_in_public_md 20 Views no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours-bijective current_method no FAED hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours-bijective current_method no FID hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours-bijective current_method no Inception Score hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours-bijective current_method no CLIPScore hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours-bijective current_method no FID hidden_in_public_md 20 Views no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours-bijective current_method no Inception Score hidden_in_public_md 20 Views no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours current_method no FAED hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours current_method no FID hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours current_method no Inception Score hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours current_method no CLIPScore hidden_in_public_md Panorama no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours current_method no FID hidden_in_public_md 20 Views no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation Ours current_method no Inception Score hidden_in_public_md 20 Views no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation MVDiffusion [47] baseline_or_reported_method no IoU hidden_in_public_md Layout Consistency no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation MVDiffusion [47] baseline_or_reported_method no IoU hidden_in_public_md Layout Consistency no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation MVDiffusion [47] baseline_or_reported_method no FID hidden_in_public_md Horizontal 8 Views [47] no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation MVDiffusion [47] baseline_or_reported_method no Inception Score hidden_in_public_md Horizontal 8 Views [47] no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset
Taming Stable Diffusion for Text to 360° Panorama Image Generation MVDiffusion [47] baseline_or_reported_method no CLIPScore hidden_in_public_md Horizontal 8 Views [47] no no missing_dataset audit_only true false missing_dataset

待补

  • 复核 paper_metric_result_review_queue.csv 的 table header、method row、dataset_role 和 eval_protocol。
  • 复核通过后写入 paper_metric_result_verified.csv,再由 sota_rankings.md 生成分榜。
  • 标注不可直接比较的指标实现差异。
  • 使用 read_priority.csv/md 作为精读优先级入口。
  • 任何 paper_claims.csv 中的强 claim,在 verified rows 为空时只能写为“作者声称/待复核”。